Bunker Mulligan "Let us endeavor so to live that when we come to die even the undertaker will be sorry." ~Mark Twain

April 14, 2004

Harbour Town

Filed under: Golf — Bunker @ 6:07 pm

Davis Love III’s “home” tournament is next, but it’s difficult to get excited about another tournament after last weekend. Love is defending, and playing well enough to repeat. The dark horse this week, and every week this season, will be Nick Price.

He’s total class. A gentleman in the mold of Byron Nelson according to several inverviews I’ve seen with his peers. That comes across when he speaks on camera. I saw him on the Golf Channel this weekend doing one of their “Playing Lessons with the Pros” features. He is completely unassuming, and genuinely friendly. Besides that, he still has one of the finest swings in the game, and his iron accuracy puts him at the top. He doesn’t hit the driver like Love, Tiger, and Phil, but he can compete through that accuracy when his putting is on.

I didn’t see Daly’s name in the field this week. That’s a disappointment. I’ve decided that the name players I’ll follow and root for this season are Big John, Ernie Els, and Nick Price. All three have the potential for a British Open win, and the US Open is within the grasp of each. Of course, the younger players are always interesting to watch as they try to get that first win.

Altruism

Filed under: International — Bunker @ 1:36 pm

I ran across Spirit of America at InstaPundit.

Americans have always been eager to help. This one may help more than most.

Some years ago I worked on a mobile radio/television studio for use in just such a situation. The whole thing was transportable by C-130, with transmission and editing studios mounted inside Humvee shelters. The antenna was something else, and required several 2-1/2 ton trucks to drag the tower structure pieces around. Anyway, it was an expensive project, supposed to be used for this type situation.

Did it all go down the drain?

April 13, 2004

War Reporting

Filed under: Society-Culture — Bunker @ 6:33 pm

Joe Galloway reminds us of wars past, and a single man in particular: Ernie Pyle.

Where are the Ernie Pyles, Bill Mauldins, and Joe Galloways of today? The reporters who put a personal touch to the people fighting the war. David Bloom was one. Kevin Sites reports from in-country, but as someone living with the civilians in a war zone rather than with soldiers.

It’s a dangerous business. Ernie was killed by a Japanese sniper. David died of a heart problem while in Baghdad. Joe was in the middle of LZ Xray. Kevin made his way into Iraq across the border with Iran.

So, why don’t we get more than a few minutes of video from a hotel rooftop? Part of it is that military folks are suspicious of the media. Too many reporters are out there to make a name for themselves. It’s understandable that reporters want recognition, but it is also contrary to the military ethos. That suspicion doesn’t last long once a relationship is established, and it’s really not a good reason to stay away from the military. Soldiers welcomed reporters as their own during the rush to Baghdad, and they became part of the team.

Maybe reporters feel unwelcome; or do they worry they can’t write a critical report on people they know? They can ease their minds. Criticism is a daily affair in the military, and GIs can take it if they know you. Not if they don’t. Ernie didn’t have to worry about this. The soldiers loved him. They respected him. He told the truth, but he told it with style and heart.

Instead of Ernie Pyle stories, the American public is bombarded by a continuous stream of the same video of burning trucks, running in a loop. Or people running away from something. Or the sound of an explosion and scenes of people ducking. I get the sense that reporters want to give us a “we are there” experience visually. Maybe they don’t have the imagination of an Ernie Pyle to do it with words. Maybe that’s all the network wants.

There are some journalists who have an aversion to any contact with military life, and others who fear the wrath of “You’re too close to the troops!”, a line we heard regarding embedded reporters. Still others don’t see the stories lying beneath the surface because they feel they have nothing in common with the young men and women around them. For most, I imagine it’s simply a matter of never having given it a thought. A few journalists, like the ones mentioned above, make the effort to get to know the troops, understand their passions and fears, and live their lives. The Ernie Pyles of today are in the minority. Hell, there was only one Ernie. But there were plenty of others at least trying to do the same thing.

I have to ask why anyone should be afraid of getting too close to the troops. Isn’t that where the best stories really are?

The Kurdish Solution

Filed under: Bunker's Favorites,International — Bunker @ 2:54 pm

The Kurds, who number 20-25 million, are the largest ethnic group in the world without their own nation. They were first mentioned in Sumerian writings in 3000 BC. What has been known as Kurdistan for more than 2500 years is spread across the northern portion of Iraq, and includes about one-third of eastern Turkey, and parts of Syria and Iran. Saddam Hussein was not the first to try to eliminate them. Every power broker in the area since the days of Darius have done so. The Kurds continue to survive. They have no friends but the mountains.

The Kurdish language has managed to survive despite efforts by Iran, Iraq, Turkey, Syria, and every conqueror who came through the area. Likewise, their culture has unbroken links to the past. They are mostly Muslim, yet view their religion in a way most Americans view our own. It does not define their way of life or politics. Their brand of Islam retains some characteristics of Zoroastrianism. Zoroastrians were led by the Magi, and some of these “wise men” visited Jesus in Bethlehem.

Saladin is most familiar historical name of all Kurds. He was born in Tikrit, Saddam’s home town. Kurdish home town. Sunnis fight with Shiites, and everyone fights the Kurds. Yet the Kurds survive. And even when the US has treated them badly or ignored them, they have retained a sense of kinship with Americans. They have little use for Europeans who agreed to the Treaty of S?vres, which outlined an autonomous Kurdistan, then rescinded it with the Treaty of Lausanne (both in 1923) to divide them among other nation-states.

Oil fields in Iraq are located in the southern, Shia area, and in the northern, Kurdish area. Much of the Sunni part of Iraq is wasteland. The Kurdish area contains oil, many minerals, and excellent farm land. It is landlocked, but a superbly viable region for autonomy.

With all the problems in Iraq, I would love to be Emperor for a Day. I would do only two things: Disband the United Nations, and hand over the northern portion of Iraq to the Kurds as an independent Kurdistan. Let the Sunni and Shia fight among themselves, as they apparently like to do, to decide who controls the southern oil fields and port of Basra. I would even give them Tikrit, and put up a strong border checkpoint which leads out of the north of the city. I would simply request a military base in Kirkuk or Mosul to station US troops and aircraft in a location convenient to trouble areas.

The Kurds have never shown any inclination to expand their territory in their entire history. They fight hard, but don’t go looking for fights. I cannot imagine a more stable democracy ever being established in the Middle East.

And you can bet it would make the French mad.

Troop Support?

Filed under: Military — Bunker @ 11:47 am

In a syndicated article this week, Andy Rooney explains Our soldiers in Iraq aren’t heroes. I really expect more from a man who spent some time as a combat reporter. Of course, that was in a real war. None of this panty-waist crap for him, boy.

It would be interesting to have a reporter ask a group of our soldiers in Iraq to answer five questions and see the results:

1. Do you think your country did the right thing sending you into Iraq?

2. Are you doing what America set out to do to make Iraq a democracy, or have we failed so badly that we should pack up and get out before more of you are killed?

3. Do the orders you get handed down from one headquarters to another, all far removed from the fighting, seem sensible, or do you think our highest command is out of touch with the reality of your situation?

4. If you could have a medal or a trip home, which would you take?

5. Are you encouraged by all the talk back home about how brave you are and how everyone supports you?

Well, gee whiz, Andy. I think I can answer most of those for you. I have to go by what I hear from my two sons who are fighting this war, and what I believe they would respond.

1. Yes.

2. If we leave now, there would be a civil war in Iraq. (Direct quote from Birdie, who is operating in Baghdad, and spent nine months in Afghanistan.)

3. My orders are general, and our company commander and platoon leaders take input from the NCOs to determine how best to accomplish them.

4. Trip home. I may be crazy, but I ain’t dumb. Which would you choose?

5. Nobody at home tells me how brave I am. They tell me to use my good instincts and lead my soldiers well. That’s real support.

God, I’m proud of my sons. I wish people like Andy Rooney were just as proud of them.

This is me!

Filed under: General Rants — Bunker @ 8:28 am

Joseph Epstein’s article, Writing on the Brain, has me pegged!

I was recently asked what it takes to become a writer. Three things, I answered: first, one must cultivate incompetence at almost every other form of profitable work. This must be accompanied, second, by a haughty contempt for all the forms of work that one has established one cannot do. To these two must be joined, third, the nuttiness to believe that other people can be made to care about your opinions and views and be charmed by the way you state them. Incompetence, contempt, lunacy?once you have these in place, you are set to go.

The article is a review of a book on brain function, The Midnight Disease, by Alice W. Flaherty. Epstein spends a lot of time discussing the science of brain function, which is what interested me, while discussing writing and its relationship to thought processes. He congratulates Flaherty for the unassuming nature of her conclusions, but disagrees with many of them:

I should like Dr. Flaherty to know that my two motives in writing this essay have been, first, to collect a decent fee, and, second, to try to knock down her book as an assemblage of profoundly muddled notions that I, given my calling, find mildly but genuinely offensive.

Really?

Filed under: International — Bunker @ 5:33 am

Do you think the chain of custody will be maintained to prove this?

The body count in Fallujah till now is 518 Iraqis dead (160 of them women, and about 50 children) and 1250 badly injured. Doctors from Fallujah mentioned that a large number of the dead women and children were shot in the head and that they were saving the extracted bullets to prove that they were being targetted by Marines snipers in the city.

Zeyad is usually not taken in by things like this. Once the “popular uprising” is done, I’ll be listening to the reporters as they condemn the account for lack of any evidence.

Of course, I could be wrong. You know those Marines…baby killers, all. Right, Son?

« Newer PostsOlder Posts »

Powered by WordPress